{
  "acquisition_sha256": "9fb748d5888eb49b58c6553377367de703cc2d698ca9f58913f35a7889094aef",
  "aggregate": {
    "baseline_strict_frames": 18,
    "native_only_positive_observations": 7,
    "native_only_strict_frames": 105,
    "native_strict_frames": 123,
    "observation_count": 7,
    "strict_null_accepts": 0,
    "validated_union_strict_frames": 123
  },
  "audit_classification": "post_exposure_independent_mechanical_audit",
  "canonical_scientific_endpoint": {
    "all_strict_frame_sets_identical_across_repeats": true,
    "interpretation": "Post-exposure sensitivity analysis only; it cannot retroactively turn the frozen v2 preregistered verdict into PASS.",
    "normalisation": "sorted unique strict AX.25 UI payload bytes",
    "status": "PASS"
  },
  "claim_boundary": {
    "independent_of_6365643_and_6365642_samples": true,
    "mission_conditioned_not_population_random": true,
    "not_a_universal_satnogs_superiority_claim": true,
    "permitted_claim_if_pass": "The fixed native branch prospectively adds strictly valid AX.25 UI frames on at least two additional untouched CELESTA observations while a validated union preserves every strict baseline frame.",
    "single_mission": true
  },
  "execution_manifests": {
    "work/positive-real-iq/celesta-confirmation-v2/baseline-identity-r1-execution.json": "cc19f5a40173821b2144c3ab90d34de7ab7a3abf20f2d1a1629baacb011adcf4",
    "work/positive-real-iq/celesta-confirmation-v2/baseline-identity-r2-execution.json": "fb592737bb4cb52710b3182056fc48eaea95d9dcaaca8c0a554e6c951c3518c2",
    "work/positive-real-iq/celesta-confirmation-v2/baseline-reversal-execution.json": "8d646a9a5e7d5023b398007a4627f394dbfda6db15ab6a58d5a5537594957f9b",
    "work/positive-real-iq/celesta-confirmation-v2/baseline-zero-execution.json": "6efd1e9bd5b28f2bdd1f90b7d27bbb4b86875bf406ccef680be8b84688cae0d7",
    "work/positive-real-iq/celesta-confirmation-v2/native-identity-r1-execution.json": "a21280f73c2e131cd8a9e8e43d6a6be655e5da2fd3ca41157ffe5b936646dbb2",
    "work/positive-real-iq/celesta-confirmation-v2/native-identity-r2-execution.json": "379cfaad5735d05d5b95c91abb111af3f9c5aa8c617446f369d9e70920ae72df",
    "work/positive-real-iq/celesta-confirmation-v2/native-reversal-execution.json": "4e1792041dfa0692d5af2ea870084069510de9e146c5832a6830bb8e44dc747e",
    "work/positive-real-iq/celesta-confirmation-v2/native-zero-execution.json": "54252688202005b6ee708ee767bf34a373c08bc5fdf2401aaed2f86d5263b07f"
  },
  "frozen_plan": {
    "path": "reports/celesta-seven-observation-confirmation-plan-v2.json",
    "sha256": "74fd68cbb2497bdcd49e39d1a3f4bdbc64add6863207d074ac32c0972eb1077f",
    "unchanged": true
  },
  "null_manifest_sha256": "fa9ad4e64dc030952523aafd001037b37afce47cafc18c3fc4d5564d7727ba06",
  "observations": [
    {
      "baseline_identity_r1": {
        "data_record_count": 2,
        "raw_sha256": "b6d320b6f3f0502c79fc939533b72b4f3d7adaf149b0652b30ad59ad41f1e20c",
        "raw_size_bytes": 532,
        "strict_set_sha256": "24188ac8a9de26568c69806eda9c7ed8a03d7a58571922d9f735edc29b6c7a1e",
        "strict_unique_count": 2,
        "timestamp_command_count": 2
      },
      "baseline_identity_r2": {
        "data_record_count": 2,
        "raw_sha256": "ac6389a5d73089ecc3003d0b84053056b2657cbb66b4a61979f53206e887ee63",
        "raw_size_bytes": 532,
        "strict_set_sha256": "24188ac8a9de26568c69806eda9c7ed8a03d7a58571922d9f735edc29b6c7a1e",
        "strict_unique_count": 2,
        "timestamp_command_count": 2
      },
      "comparison": {
        "baseline_only": 0,
        "baseline_strict": 2,
        "intersection": 2,
        "native_only": 16,
        "native_strict": 18,
        "validated_union": 18
      },
      "native_identity_r1": {
        "raw_sha256": "e32353d3661b791821d22a3d1a731cb101411351753ba266023c1fe630e040ea",
        "raw_size_bytes": 82477,
        "reference_firewall_pass": true,
        "strict_set_sha256": "c4686af6e90f5c1424b085152775a01f0247ac8e12eaff01ea582ab7f8a7c2c6",
        "strict_unique_count": 18
      },
      "native_identity_r2": {
        "raw_sha256": "e32353d3661b791821d22a3d1a731cb101411351753ba266023c1fe630e040ea",
        "raw_size_bytes": 82477,
        "reference_firewall_pass": true,
        "strict_set_sha256": "c4686af6e90f5c1424b085152775a01f0247ac8e12eaff01ea582ab7f8a7c2c6",
        "strict_unique_count": 18
      },
      "null_strict": {
        "reversal": {
          "baseline_strict": 0,
          "native_strict": 0
        },
        "zero": {
          "baseline_strict": 0,
          "native_strict": 0
        }
      },
      "observation_id": 6215698,
      "repeatability": {
        "baseline_canonical_strict_set_identical": true,
        "baseline_raw_bytes_identical": false,
        "native_canonical_strict_set_identical": true,
        "native_raw_bytes_identical": true
      },
      "same_iq": {
        "complex_samples": 34314089,
        "etag": "82e5da4-5e3bfa9b71624",
        "observation_id": 6215698,
        "path": "work/positive-real-iq/celesta-confirmation-v2/obs-6215698/iq_6215698.raw",
        "sha256": "aeea8f27597d39256094e823996541deca37165dd2dc1d44d2e7542e8b2b63c5",
        "size_bytes": 137256356
      }
    },
    {
      "baseline_identity_r1": {
        "data_record_count": 5,
        "raw_sha256": "93226fa1e61bd8031dd738e934caf6c9210591c685eb8fc4faeae23b30b29b95",
        "raw_size_bytes": 1331,
        "strict_set_sha256": "156c6bf2014989f010fe491b2ff6ca70dc57b633e188513a4dceced3091bc85c",
        "strict_unique_count": 5,
        "timestamp_command_count": 5
      },
      "baseline_identity_r2": {
        "data_record_count": 6,
        "raw_sha256": "0055ee2a81c1952c4135c70d0e348e01a2ee6a5166c00ffe156562be00ecdd13",
        "raw_size_bytes": 1348,
        "strict_set_sha256": "156c6bf2014989f010fe491b2ff6ca70dc57b633e188513a4dceced3091bc85c",
        "strict_unique_count": 5,
        "timestamp_command_count": 6
      },
      "comparison": {
        "baseline_only": 0,
        "baseline_strict": 5,
        "intersection": 5,
        "native_only": 12,
        "native_strict": 17,
        "validated_union": 17
      },
      "native_identity_r1": {
        "raw_sha256": "3517ac63cda782e93a42f3ecc95f8a096f44dab1546f1b66d92af43fc9173d4f",
        "raw_size_bytes": 80201,
        "reference_firewall_pass": true,
        "strict_set_sha256": "63ffed35ab72ffc8ee7977b58fc45df4b7d73771f4afd55fceea3bf496c49dfb",
        "strict_unique_count": 17
      },
      "native_identity_r2": {
        "raw_sha256": "3517ac63cda782e93a42f3ecc95f8a096f44dab1546f1b66d92af43fc9173d4f",
        "raw_size_bytes": 80201,
        "reference_firewall_pass": true,
        "strict_set_sha256": "63ffed35ab72ffc8ee7977b58fc45df4b7d73771f4afd55fceea3bf496c49dfb",
        "strict_unique_count": 17
      },
      "null_strict": {
        "reversal": {
          "baseline_strict": 0,
          "native_strict": 0
        },
        "zero": {
          "baseline_strict": 0,
          "native_strict": 0
        }
      },
      "observation_id": 6221405,
      "repeatability": {
        "baseline_canonical_strict_set_identical": true,
        "baseline_raw_bytes_identical": false,
        "native_canonical_strict_set_identical": true,
        "native_raw_bytes_identical": true
      },
      "same_iq": {
        "complex_samples": 34320164,
        "etag": "82ebc90-5e3dd24f47146",
        "observation_id": 6221405,
        "path": "work/positive-real-iq/celesta-confirmation-v2/obs-6221405/iq_6221405.raw",
        "sha256": "c87129b0e147fe087bfd1b1e7660e3f03dc571b7fe12137f0dd4aff7e9651d25",
        "size_bytes": 137280656
      }
    },
    {
      "baseline_identity_r1": {
        "data_record_count": 3,
        "raw_sha256": "dc9c282851b10443a43f4da12af283d2f6ae447c12141312f2b0259eeaa9862a",
        "raw_size_bytes": 800,
        "strict_set_sha256": "387f1fcf99bce5e3d94b30c88d05e29dfac45e7ab86d4e40fe52d979d60e9457",
        "strict_unique_count": 3,
        "timestamp_command_count": 3
      },
      "baseline_identity_r2": {
        "data_record_count": 3,
        "raw_sha256": "6a211ecd2f387311b9c2bddbbf13c6f8dfdf5c075edcea09bebb6be85969b470",
        "raw_size_bytes": 800,
        "strict_set_sha256": "387f1fcf99bce5e3d94b30c88d05e29dfac45e7ab86d4e40fe52d979d60e9457",
        "strict_unique_count": 3,
        "timestamp_command_count": 3
      },
      "comparison": {
        "baseline_only": 0,
        "baseline_strict": 3,
        "intersection": 3,
        "native_only": 17,
        "native_strict": 20,
        "validated_union": 20
      },
      "native_identity_r1": {
        "raw_sha256": "93a426484cff4f3b5eaee53cb84e1974e212eee0f6e9a45f528a26a185646301",
        "raw_size_bytes": 92859,
        "reference_firewall_pass": true,
        "strict_set_sha256": "26ab1c2292987fd2899bd1a597409363dc9334839aaa724d7fd9d54e6ca1a9a8",
        "strict_unique_count": 20
      },
      "native_identity_r2": {
        "raw_sha256": "93a426484cff4f3b5eaee53cb84e1974e212eee0f6e9a45f528a26a185646301",
        "raw_size_bytes": 92859,
        "reference_firewall_pass": true,
        "strict_set_sha256": "26ab1c2292987fd2899bd1a597409363dc9334839aaa724d7fd9d54e6ca1a9a8",
        "strict_unique_count": 20
      },
      "null_strict": {
        "reversal": {
          "baseline_strict": 0,
          "native_strict": 0
        },
        "zero": {
          "baseline_strict": 0,
          "native_strict": 0
        }
      },
      "observation_id": 6284801,
      "repeatability": {
        "baseline_canonical_strict_set_identical": true,
        "baseline_raw_bytes_identical": false,
        "native_canonical_strict_set_identical": true,
        "native_raw_bytes_identical": true
      },
      "same_iq": {
        "complex_samples": 38161087,
        "etag": "9192afc-5e52e98d01689",
        "observation_id": 6284801,
        "path": "work/positive-real-iq/celesta-confirmation-v2/obs-6284801/iq_6284801.raw",
        "sha256": "7fbf92b45c6092cd4dd4e72fa6c3ab70c9c6f67e2ec3c682d5175e461ab0a674",
        "size_bytes": 152644348
      }
    },
    {
      "baseline_identity_r1": {
        "data_record_count": 5,
        "raw_sha256": "d165bed393e8015c8013981d54ecc1a331770647f47ab037e6739c8e5c948a7d",
        "raw_size_bytes": 1094,
        "strict_set_sha256": "6e5795cda641884e568efd777a62f958c824c2690a60047a1e5562216d97d2af",
        "strict_unique_count": 4,
        "timestamp_command_count": 5
      },
      "baseline_identity_r2": {
        "data_record_count": 5,
        "raw_sha256": "a5d931b248f6c6a5808b0050bf0b5f52c58904b5b5ce4d519aee0a636e62bc93",
        "raw_size_bytes": 1095,
        "strict_set_sha256": "6e5795cda641884e568efd777a62f958c824c2690a60047a1e5562216d97d2af",
        "strict_unique_count": 4,
        "timestamp_command_count": 5
      },
      "comparison": {
        "baseline_only": 0,
        "baseline_strict": 4,
        "intersection": 4,
        "native_only": 14,
        "native_strict": 18,
        "validated_union": 18
      },
      "native_identity_r1": {
        "raw_sha256": "f56326e50db4ffae8d47fe35dbb2408ffe44393ee1298899be6c4c45b02b1382",
        "raw_size_bytes": 82365,
        "reference_firewall_pass": true,
        "strict_set_sha256": "57635ecbae809c29929c1a4152075425e07c91c1c5530d1b85d42631174863b0",
        "strict_unique_count": 18
      },
      "native_identity_r2": {
        "raw_sha256": "f56326e50db4ffae8d47fe35dbb2408ffe44393ee1298899be6c4c45b02b1382",
        "raw_size_bytes": 82365,
        "reference_firewall_pass": true,
        "strict_set_sha256": "57635ecbae809c29929c1a4152075425e07c91c1c5530d1b85d42631174863b0",
        "strict_unique_count": 18
      },
      "null_strict": {
        "reversal": {
          "baseline_strict": 0,
          "native_strict": 0
        },
        "zero": {
          "baseline_strict": 0,
          "native_strict": 0
        }
      },
      "observation_id": 6291502,
      "repeatability": {
        "baseline_canonical_strict_set_identical": true,
        "baseline_raw_bytes_identical": false,
        "native_canonical_strict_set_identical": true,
        "native_raw_bytes_identical": true
      },
      "same_iq": {
        "complex_samples": 34308621,
        "etag": "82e0834-5e5536ffe6110",
        "observation_id": 6291502,
        "path": "work/positive-real-iq/celesta-confirmation-v2/obs-6291502/iq_6291502.raw",
        "sha256": "2cf6820f227996961a2d902942bdbe8a6dbc0a6e56dcaa3257f755f4a9301372",
        "size_bytes": 137234484
      }
    },
    {
      "baseline_identity_r1": {
        "data_record_count": 2,
        "raw_sha256": "349ceaa9aa557886839df16503e699a02bd554ce90829321e20063a9822fb7ae",
        "raw_size_bytes": 310,
        "strict_set_sha256": "5018376735ec2ae2e28305cf59d8182775b032155c87837ecb684fbbd9909a3e",
        "strict_unique_count": 1,
        "timestamp_command_count": 2
      },
      "baseline_identity_r2": {
        "data_record_count": 2,
        "raw_sha256": "9e095ac1bd81c7e20eb047cf61b7f22d4d05db0fb350be0e1c93bed9fd73dd16",
        "raw_size_bytes": 310,
        "strict_set_sha256": "5018376735ec2ae2e28305cf59d8182775b032155c87837ecb684fbbd9909a3e",
        "strict_unique_count": 1,
        "timestamp_command_count": 2
      },
      "comparison": {
        "baseline_only": 0,
        "baseline_strict": 1,
        "intersection": 1,
        "native_only": 16,
        "native_strict": 17,
        "validated_union": 17
      },
      "native_identity_r1": {
        "raw_sha256": "8e8494f52907f114d04e81d488c2da0c26aa4a89b6faa9c006c9aa6e1f94e15b",
        "raw_size_bytes": 80714,
        "reference_firewall_pass": true,
        "strict_set_sha256": "39fad078fcc742ac26c390d404d97ca077d403d280d422648155d22e2f88d0fd",
        "strict_unique_count": 17
      },
      "native_identity_r2": {
        "raw_sha256": "8e8494f52907f114d04e81d488c2da0c26aa4a89b6faa9c006c9aa6e1f94e15b",
        "raw_size_bytes": 80714,
        "reference_firewall_pass": true,
        "strict_set_sha256": "39fad078fcc742ac26c390d404d97ca077d403d280d422648155d22e2f88d0fd",
        "strict_unique_count": 17
      },
      "null_strict": {
        "reversal": {
          "baseline_strict": 0,
          "native_strict": 0
        },
        "zero": {
          "baseline_strict": 0,
          "native_strict": 0
        }
      },
      "observation_id": 6291503,
      "repeatability": {
        "baseline_canonical_strict_set_identical": true,
        "baseline_raw_bytes_identical": false,
        "native_canonical_strict_set_identical": true,
        "native_raw_bytes_identical": true
      },
      "same_iq": {
        "complex_samples": 34312929,
        "etag": "82e4b84-5e553701a2665",
        "observation_id": 6291503,
        "path": "work/positive-real-iq/celesta-confirmation-v2/obs-6291503/iq_6291503.raw",
        "sha256": "3b285be9b9013dee4f62aecbe46a725f1756aefe81e0134f959f079e2bf9568f",
        "size_bytes": 137251716
      }
    },
    {
      "baseline_identity_r1": {
        "data_record_count": 1,
        "raw_sha256": "7a4157f361f702a89cda2f1c4847655986aa605dd11cbaed04960b4b77a306d7",
        "raw_size_bytes": 266,
        "strict_set_sha256": "b8c0be9152c8b90424101a99d484b01a799d84b3bf05746af986909bbd771e84",
        "strict_unique_count": 1,
        "timestamp_command_count": 1
      },
      "baseline_identity_r2": {
        "data_record_count": 1,
        "raw_sha256": "8b140e399a86f1f3120ff5ad33859ee71b80e17ea51064c1ea06cadbdf2dbdd2",
        "raw_size_bytes": 266,
        "strict_set_sha256": "b8c0be9152c8b90424101a99d484b01a799d84b3bf05746af986909bbd771e84",
        "strict_unique_count": 1,
        "timestamp_command_count": 1
      },
      "comparison": {
        "baseline_only": 0,
        "baseline_strict": 1,
        "intersection": 1,
        "native_only": 16,
        "native_strict": 17,
        "validated_union": 17
      },
      "native_identity_r1": {
        "raw_sha256": "a3423c93bd38a1d0bd16f7f08b7157caaa6249d39d76d357ab9554f5b2ba5fdf",
        "raw_size_bytes": 80118,
        "reference_firewall_pass": true,
        "strict_set_sha256": "512d30bc5ea3630b01acbdb6bb5cb0919690865ad3a181c2bdd9f35807d92e04",
        "strict_unique_count": 17
      },
      "native_identity_r2": {
        "raw_sha256": "a3423c93bd38a1d0bd16f7f08b7157caaa6249d39d76d357ab9554f5b2ba5fdf",
        "raw_size_bytes": 80118,
        "reference_firewall_pass": true,
        "strict_set_sha256": "512d30bc5ea3630b01acbdb6bb5cb0919690865ad3a181c2bdd9f35807d92e04",
        "strict_unique_count": 17
      },
      "null_strict": {
        "reversal": {
          "baseline_strict": 0,
          "native_strict": 0
        },
        "zero": {
          "baseline_strict": 0,
          "native_strict": 0
        }
      },
      "observation_id": 6357041,
      "repeatability": {
        "baseline_canonical_strict_set_identical": true,
        "baseline_raw_bytes_identical": false,
        "native_canonical_strict_set_identical": true,
        "native_raw_bytes_identical": true
      },
      "same_iq": {
        "complex_samples": 34319847,
        "etag": "82eb79c-5e69a7f50102b",
        "observation_id": 6357041,
        "path": "work/positive-real-iq/celesta-confirmation-v2/obs-6357041/iq_6357041.raw",
        "sha256": "aec7486030876bb34b87488fc8cc8a649d54fe2d5666a97ecf6c60aa78cb8ea0",
        "size_bytes": 137279388
      }
    },
    {
      "baseline_identity_r1": {
        "data_record_count": 4,
        "raw_sha256": "9141bf43575dc19763a70f8d0bd01b0e588f5314fa34b81d5265132ccfdf9a23",
        "raw_size_bytes": 576,
        "strict_set_sha256": "58fc880f0d962363464c2255247c629fc07e533809413067fdd4fd3dca2f8f9a",
        "strict_unique_count": 2,
        "timestamp_command_count": 4
      },
      "baseline_identity_r2": {
        "data_record_count": 3,
        "raw_sha256": "b2ee90d2fb73d1373d8f59e541398966f82f0b6e1c7f37921a1c641e9ef4fd84",
        "raw_size_bytes": 556,
        "strict_set_sha256": "58fc880f0d962363464c2255247c629fc07e533809413067fdd4fd3dca2f8f9a",
        "strict_unique_count": 2,
        "timestamp_command_count": 3
      },
      "comparison": {
        "baseline_only": 0,
        "baseline_strict": 2,
        "intersection": 2,
        "native_only": 14,
        "native_strict": 16,
        "validated_union": 16
      },
      "native_identity_r1": {
        "raw_sha256": "0e0019cd0b7feb5bfb3d05c3c59db31ec48247c070ab293827cc4ab360e2d1ad",
        "raw_size_bytes": 83727,
        "reference_firewall_pass": true,
        "strict_set_sha256": "5020032919637781a7986cdf7fddf9acb5a8b46f2f146445b6005c3e27e72e47",
        "strict_unique_count": 16
      },
      "native_identity_r2": {
        "raw_sha256": "0e0019cd0b7feb5bfb3d05c3c59db31ec48247c070ab293827cc4ab360e2d1ad",
        "raw_size_bytes": 83727,
        "reference_firewall_pass": true,
        "strict_set_sha256": "5020032919637781a7986cdf7fddf9acb5a8b46f2f146445b6005c3e27e72e47",
        "strict_unique_count": 16
      },
      "null_strict": {
        "reversal": {
          "baseline_strict": 0,
          "native_strict": 0
        },
        "zero": {
          "baseline_strict": 0,
          "native_strict": 0
        }
      },
      "observation_id": 6357042,
      "repeatability": {
        "baseline_canonical_strict_set_identical": true,
        "baseline_raw_bytes_identical": false,
        "native_canonical_strict_set_identical": true,
        "native_raw_bytes_identical": true
      },
      "same_iq": {
        "complex_samples": 39498296,
        "etag": "96ac8e0-5e69a7f6d1da0",
        "observation_id": 6357042,
        "path": "work/positive-real-iq/celesta-confirmation-v2/obs-6357042/iq_6357042.raw",
        "sha256": "3d5131a22d5b656fcb7b81b5759f0c7d454443643faac38463001803ea52bf16",
        "size_bytes": 157993184
      }
    }
  ],
  "preregistered_v2_verdict": {
    "all_identity_outputs_byte_identical": false,
    "all_nulls_zero_strict": true,
    "baseline_preserved_by_union": true,
    "failure_reason": "The baseline KISS containers are not byte-identical across repeats.",
    "minimum_two_native_only_positive_observations": true,
    "minimum_two_native_only_strict_frames": true,
    "overall": false
  },
  "schema_version": "celesta-seven-observation-confirmation-v2-independent-audit",
  "status": "FAIL_PREREGISTERED_CRITERION"
}